Nevada Pierre was just three years old when he was expelled from a Florida toddler soccer league just one day ago. His infraction? Playing soccer against boys older than him so well that they couldn't compete with him - while also being black. Police were called to the game, and the league then removed the family and refunded their fees, and officers made no arrests. The rationale offered, in effect, was that the boy was "too good." His family and many observers perceive that rationale as a thin disguise for racial animus, and with good reason.
If the contest was supposed to uncover new talent at an early age, they found it - and just didn't like the colour of skin it came wrapped in. The incident drips with racism, white privilege, entitlement and a disturbing level of adult emotional immaturity. Imagine being the sort of parent who calls the cops on a three-year-old for the offence of being better at a game than the other children? "Karen" doesn't even come close to describing that level of malfunction.
Put side by side, a pattern emerges from these two stories.
In both cases, exceptional black skill, ability and achievement was reframed as a problem to be investigated, punished and expelled. In the case of Arday, formal vindication did little to stop the machinery of scrutiny once racialised suspicion had been switched on. This is consistent with what scholars and commentators describe as a reaction to black excellence in settings shaped by white fragility - a reaction that demands: "How dare anyone be so talented, skilled, proficient or successful, and not be white?"
The result is a drive to eject those deemed "too successful" or "too good" who don't match the majoritarian demographic. The "Get outta here - you're making us look bad!" drive adds a dimension of protectionism to an already roiling cauldron of individual jealousy, resentment, racism and elitism. It also clears the way for a no-holds-barred assault intended to destroy the target on every level: scrutinising and dismantling everything they ever said, did or achieved, and hunting for ways to distort or misrepresent them, their intentions or their achievements in whatever sinister form proves useful - as happened in the case of Arday. It is still too early to tell how the life and future career of Pierre will progress, but I sincerely hope it will have a happy, successful outcome.
In Arday's case, once that machinery started, it did not stop - not even after his death. It persists in the laugh emojis and bullying comments left on continuing media coverage on his vindication by people who openly reject anything that contradicts their preferred narrative: that Arday was a "DEI hire," that he did not deserve or earn his qualifications, that he lied, cheated and plagiarised. For most white scholars accused of wrongdoing, one formal investigation is enough to vindicate them professionally and publicly. In Arday's case, not even four have been enough.
Being successful and excellent is fine if you're white - but if you're black and excellent - and even worse, black and excellent in a majority-white environment, then there's clearly something suspicious going on.
Please explain it to me, in plain English, why that inconsistency is not about race?
What truly disgusts me about the society we share is how easily an innocent life - a man's, a woman's, a child's - can be ruined. How a successful and productive career can be derailed, sabotaged and cut short by something as basal and useless as hate and the perveyance of lies and misinformation. And make no mistake: the hatred fuelled by racism and pseudo-scientific Nazi-era fallacies like eugenics is what lies behind this pointless, cruel and wasteful death. What is truly outrageous about this trend of the value and humanity of a human being being determined by the colour-tone of their skin is what happened yesterday in Florida, when a three-year-old boy had to endure the same hatred from insecure, small-minded adults who could not stand that a small black boy was dominating a game of soccer and their children lacked the skills and talent to compete.
Removing the competition is one way to guarantee your own success, apparently. But what does that say about your own skills?
Erasure, though, does not always need a campaign. Sometimes it needs only an obituary and an opportunist.
Alice Ball was a gifted young African-American chemist who, in 1915, developed the first effective injectable treatment for leprosy while working at the College of Hawaii. By chemically modifying chaulmoogra oil to make its active esters water-soluble, she freed many patients from quarantine. This method - the Ball Method - was widely used before antibiotics. Ball was also the first woman and the first African-American to earn a master's degree in chemistry at the College of Hawaii, and became its first black chemistry instructor.
She died in 1916, aged 24, after a laboratory accident - before publishing her findings. Her graduate advisor, Arthur L. Dean, continued producing the treatment - but published her research without crediting her and renamed it the "Dean Method", claiming it as his own. Ball's contribution to medical science was erased for decades. As Ball was not white, and Dean was, earlier attempts to correct the record were ignored. However, her work was since restored to her as the Ball Method, with honours including a plaque at the University of Hawaii and Alice Ball Day. All of it came far too late to be of benefit to Alice Ball, though, didn't it - whose work was stolen, plagiarized, by the man who supervised her and passed off as his own for the better part of a century.
That example speaks to how little has changed in a hundred years, doesn't it?
There's a social hierarchy that seeks to push people into little pigeon-holes that suit their social station, to sort through the soup of diversity until it more closely resembles a segregated, stratified, colour-coded cocktail drink. White males go on top, naturally. Where everyone else - the women, the people of colour, and which colours - fits into this stratigraphy, is immaterial to those on top, just so long as they get to keep their place on top. From there they can reap all the limelight, accolades, the attention, the praise and rewards for their brilliance and their achievements. And of course, determine how much, if any, of that filters down to the other levels.
But let someone from one of the lower tiers dare outshine those at the top, or show them up - or make them feel threatened, or unable to compete against them fairly, and noses get put out of joint. It's the same in every hierarchy of this type.
When I see people attacking the memory of Professor Arday, and cheering the treatment this child and his parents received, and worshiping at the altar of Arthur Dean, and see how racism underlies the arguments and motives of the sort of people who will not share the world with others, it emphasizes why this matters. It is why we must actively and collectively oppose the erasure of minorities from academia - and why there must be no room in academic institutions (or in fact, ANY institutions) for racism or racist ideologies.
And not just in institutions. In society too. Because a system that can clear a man four times and still bury him is not a system that self-rectifies, is self-accountable, or has been fixed. Rather, it is a system that has learned to file the paperwork.
References:
American Chemical Society. (n.d.). Alice Augusta Ball: A trailblazing chemist created a viable treatment for leprosy. ACS National Historic Chemical Landmarks. https://www.acs.org/education/whatischemistry/landmarks/alice-ball.html
Brewster, C. D. (2018, February 28). How the woman who found a leprosy treatment was almost lost to history. National Geographic. https://www.nationalgeographic.com/science/article/alice-ball-leprosy-hansens-disease-hawaii-womens-history-science
Caldbick, J. (2026, May 3). Ball, Alice Augusta (1892–1916). HistoryLink.org. https://www.historylink.org/File/23522
Hawaiʻi State Senate. (2023). Senate Concurrent Resolution No. 159: Urging the Board of Regents of the University of Hawaii to rename Dean Hall at the University of Hawaii at Mānoa to "Alice Ball Hall." https://www.capitol.hawaii.gov/sessions/session2023/bills/SCR159_.HTM
Ibe, N. (2026, October 21). Investigations fail to substantiate claims against late Cambridge professor. Leadership. https://leadership.ng/investigations-fail-to-substantiate-claims-against-late-cambridge-professor/
Jason Arday "endured three weeks of relentless scrutiny" before his death says John Moores University. (n.d.). Liverpool Echo. https://www.liverpoolecho.co.uk/news/liverpool-news/tragedy-jason-ardays-death-felt-34474858
Okundaye, J. (2026, August 6). The takedown of Jason Arday has overjoyed the right, and must be a wake-up call for the left. The Guardian. https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2026/aug/06/jason-arday-dei-race-issues-university-of-cambridge
Overlooked No More: Alice Ball, chemist who created a treatment for leprosy. (2023, April 8). The New York Times. https://www.nytimes.com/2023/04/08/obituaries/alice-ball-overlooked.html
Stechyson, N. (2026, October 26). Florida parents say police called to 3-year-old's soccer game because kid was "too good." CBC News. https://www.cbc.ca/lite/story/9.7396158
University of Hawaiʻi System News. (2026, February 26). 'Ball Method' declared national historic landmark at Alice Ball celebration. https://www.hawaii.edu/news/2026/02/26/ball-method-national-landmark/
Was Jason Arday really a serial plagiarist? No, the evidence shows. (2026, August 26). Middle East Eye. https://www.middleeasteye.net/news/was-jason-arday-really-serial-plagiarist-no-evidence-shows
Black 3-year-old soccer prodigy kicked out of Florida league for being "Too Good." (2026, October 27). GhanaWeb. https://www.ghanaweb.com/GhanaHomePage/SportsArchive/Black-3-year-old-soccer-prodigy-kicked-out-of-Florida-league-for-being-Too-Good-2058608


No comments:
Post a Comment